Guide · 4 min read

Benefits of using a health insurance broker vs an insurance company

You can buy private health insurance directly from an insurer or through an intermediary. The useful questions are which products they compare, whether they give a personal recommendation, how they are paid and what support they provide after the sale. The label “broker” alone does not answer all four.

Speak to an Adviser

Written by Patrick Baxter, Founder & Health Insurance Broker

Fact-checked by Sadie Sansford, Business Development Director

Updated 15 September 2026

4 min read

What This Guide Covers

Buying direct from an insurance company

What health insurance agents do

What health insurance brokers do

Side-by-side benefits comparison

Do brokers charge fees?

Health insurance agent vs broker comparison — an agent represents one insurance company, a broker represents multiple — Health insurance agent vs broker — what's the difference?

5.0 · Google reviews

Expertly comparing the UK’s leading providers

Read our independent provider reviews →

★★★★★ 5.0 on Google · Google reviews · FCA Authorised · Free advice · No obligation

Broker

Independent advice across a range of insurers. Ask which providers are included and how the broker is paid.

Agent

Works for one or a few insurers and arranges cover on their behalf. Ask which insurers it represents.

Direct

Buy from the insurer yourself. Full control, but no independent advice or comparison.

Three Routes Agents Brokers Broker or Direct?Fees

Buying health insurance

Broker, Agent or Direct: How the Three Routes Differ

A broker can help you compare the insurers within its service and explain the differences. Buying direct lets you discuss an insurer’s own products with that insurer. Before choosing either route, establish whether you are receiving advice, which products are considered and how the service is paid for.

Buying routes compared
Route	Product scope	Advice and payment questions
Broker	The range it actually considers. Do not assume the entire market.	Is a recommendation provided? Which insurers are included? Is it paid by commission, a customer fee, or both?
Restricted intermediary or agent	One or more insurers under the firm’s stated arrangement	Which insurers does it represent or work with? What advice and ongoing service does it offer?
Direct insurer	That insurer’s available products	Is the sale advised or information-only? What support is available when choosing and at renewal?

Ask about any fee before you proceed. Where a fee applies, the firm must disclose the amount, or the basis for calculating it, before you become liable. Insurers and intermediaries alike must act in customers’ interests, so a direct sale is not unregulated: the difference is scope and advice, not whether your interests count. For how medical history is assessed see underwriting, and for checking a renewal see am I paying too much?

An insurer can explain and sell its own products. Buying direct can suit someone who has already compared the options and is comfortable deciding which cover to choose. Ask whether the sale includes a personal recommendation or information only.

You will need to compare other insurers yourself if you want a wider view. Direct purchase is not automatically the cheapest route: compare the final premium, benefits, excess, hospital access and underwriting with any intermediary quote.

Whichever route you use, the insurer’s accepted terms determine the cover. Do not cancel an existing policy before the replacement is confirmed.

Buying health insurance

What Does an Insurance Agent Do?

An intermediary may deal with one insurer or a limited group. Its authority and role depend on the actual arrangement. Ask whose products it offers and whether it recommends a policy or simply arranges your selection.

Do not assume that an agent can put cover in force before underwriting is complete. Request written acceptance and the effective start date. Nor should you assume that someone working for an insurer is free to disregard the customer’s interests.

Buying health insurance

What Can a Health Insurance Broker Help With?

A broker can compare available products, explain benefit differences and help you assess underwriting and switching terms. Some cover a panel of insurers; others describe a broader market service. Ask which insurers and products were considered and whether any were excluded.

Support at renewal or during a claim varies by firm. A broker may help explain or query an insurer’s decision, but cannot guarantee acceptance, remove a contractual exclusion or promise the lowest market price.

The FCA’s customer-best-interests rule applies to firms distributing insurance; it is not a duty exclusive to brokers. Read ICOBS 2.5.

Want independent broker advice? My Health Protected charges no customer advice fee.

Buying health insurance

Should you buy health insurance through a broker or directly?

Neither route is automatically better or cheaper. What differs is the advice offered, the range of providers included and how the service is paid for, so ask the questions below of whichever route you are considering.

Questions to ask a broker, agent or insurer
Question	What a useful answer tells you
Which products are considered?	One insurer, a named panel or a wider search; any material exclusions from that search.
Is this advice?	Whether you receive a personal recommendation or make the choice from information.
How are you paid?	Commission, a customer fee or another arrangement.
What happens after purchase?	The actual renewal, administration and claim support offered.
Are the quotes equivalent?	Matching benefits, hospital access, excess and medical-history terms.

Keep the recommendation, reasons and final policy documents. If a lower quote removes cover you need, it is not the same purchase at a better price.

Buying health insurance

Do Health Insurance Brokers Charge Fees?

Some intermediaries charge a customer fee; others receive commission from the insurer, and arrangements can combine both. It is incorrect to say that all brokers are free.

The FCA requires disclosure of the nature of remuneration. If a fee is payable, its amount or calculation basis must be explained before you become liable. Commission is remuneration included in the premium; it does not establish that direct purchase will be cheaper. FCA remuneration and fee disclosure rules.

My Health Protected’s advice service is offered without a customer advice fee, as described on this site. Ask us how we are remunerated and which providers are included in your comparison. Free advice does not mean a guaranteed saving or a promise to cover the whole market without qualification.

In Conclusion

A broker can help you compare the providers it covers and understand the proposed terms. You can also buy directly from an insurer. Compare the advice offered, provider choice, fees, benefits and medical-history terms before deciding which route suits you.

Get Started

Ready for Free Broker Advice?

We compare across a range of insurers on your behalf, including providers like AXA Health, Bupa, Aviva and more. No customer advice fee. Get impartial advice from an FCA-authorised independent broker.

0203 859 1822